Have you ever noticed how esteemed cigar review sites like Cigar Aficionado can give wildly different ratings to cigars with the same blend of tobacco, just in different sizes? It’s not a mistake or a case of the reviewers having a bad day—it’s science (and maybe a touch of personal preference). The size of a cigar drastically impacts its intensity and burn, which means that even with identical tobacco, the experience can feel like comparing a smooth jazz concert to a rock festival. Both are enjoyable, but they hit entirely different notes.
The main difference between a Toro and a Robusto is about an inch—literally. A Toro is typically longer and has a larger diameter, which affects how it burns and how the flavors develop over time. The extra size gives the Toro a slower, cooler burn, while the smaller Robusto delivers a punchier, more concentrated experience. It’s proof that size really does matter—at least when it comes to cigars.
How Big is a Robusto?
Robusto cigars are known for their compact size and rich smoking experience. After all, they were named after the Spanish word for "robust, strong." Typically, a Robusto measures between 4.75 to 5.5 inches in length with a ring gauge of 48 to 52. This size is perfect for those who seek a shorter, more intense smoking session. The smaller length allows the smoker to enjoy the cigar's flavors more quickly, often leading to a stronger initial taste due to the heat being closer to the mouth.
This size became immensely popular in the late 1980s, appealing to both novice and experienced smokers who appreciate a full-bodied flavor in a shorter time. The Robusto is ideal for a 30 to 40-minute smoke, making it a favorite for those who want to enjoy a premium cigar without committing to a long session. Notable examples include the Ashton Magnum, La Aroma de Cuba Robusto, and Padron 1964 Anniversary Exclusivo, each offering a unique and satisfying experience.
How Big is a Toro?
Toro cigars are slightly larger, generally measuring 6 to 6.5 inches in length with a ring gauge of 52 to 54. This size provides a longer smoking experience, typically lasting from 45 minutes to over an hour. The Toro is perfect for smokers who prefer a more extended and balanced session. The longer length allows for a slower burn and a more gradual development of flavors, providing a nuanced smoking experience.
The Toro is often considered a 'grande' option, akin to a larger coffee size at Starbucks, offering a satisfying duration for those who enjoy taking their time with a cigar. Notable examples include the Flor de las Antillas Toro, Padron Family Reserve No. 45, and one of my personal favorites, La Aroma de Cuba Monarch. Each of these cigars delivers a rich and complex flavor profile, making the Toro a preferred choice for many aficionados.
For more information regarding popular cigar sizes, please see our Cigar Shapes & Sizes Guide for helpful comparisons as well as a size chart.
Toro vs Robusto: Which Is Best?
Interestingly, while the Robusto once reigned supreme as the king of cigar sizes—Cigar Aficionado even dubbed the 2000s the “Robusto generation”—the Toro has since claimed the throne. In 2007, Robustos dominated cigar sales, but by 2020, a survey by Cigar Aficionado revealed that Robusto sales had dropped to just 24%, while Toro sales had surged to 51.7%.
Fast forward to 2023, and the trend was even more pronounced: Toro accounted for nearly 70% of cigar sales, while Robusto slid to just above 13.5%. This shift highlights the growing preference among cigar enthusiasts for a longer, more relaxed smoking experience that the Toro delivers.
Ultimately, choosing between a Robusto and a Toro comes down to personal preference. The best way to decide? Grab one of each from the same blend and see which suits your style. Some people enjoy the quicker, punchier experience of a Robusto, while others prefer the slow, drawn-out enjoyment of a Toro. That’s exactly how I figured out I’m more of a Robusto guy—it’s all about finding what works for you.
