When it comes to cigars, the Arturo Fuente Hemingway line is like the well-dressed guy at the bar who doesn’t have to tell you he’s classy—you just know. With its vintage Perfecto shape (that taper at both ends is no accident), this line is all about craftsmanship and legacy. Named after Ernest Hemingway, it’s fitting that these cigars are as much a work of art as the author’s best novels—only these you can enjoy with a glass of bourbon without getting funny looks.
If you’re new to the Hemingway line or just looking to deepen your appreciation, let’s talk about the two MVPs of the lineup: the Short Story and the Best Seller. Both are masterclasses in cigar-making, but they offer two distinct smoking experiences that deserve a proper deep dive.
What Makes the Hemingway Line Special?
The Hemingway line isn’t just a group of cigars—it’s a nod to tradition. These Dominican-made beauties are rolled in a Perfecto shape that harks back to pre-embargo Cuban cigars. The Fuente family revived this style in the 1980s, and it’s been a hit ever since. Each Hemingway cigar is wrapped in a gorgeous Cameroon wrapper, housing a blend of aged Dominican fillers that scream (or whisper) sophistication.
One unique feature is the signature “nipple” at the foot of the cigar, which makes lighting it a breeze and ensures a smooth, bold, and controlled start to your smoking experience. It’s a small detail, but one that sets the tone for the level of craftsmanship packed into each stick.
No matter which cigar you choose from this line, you can expect a consistently smooth, flavorful smoke that balances richness with subtlety. It’s the kind of cigar you light up when you want to feel like a big deal—whether you’re at a wedding, a golf course, or just hiding from your in-laws in the garage.
Short Story: Small But Mighty
Specs:
- Size: 4 x 49
- Smoke Time: ~30-45 minutes
- Flavor Notes: Cedar, maple, nuts, and a dash of spice
The Short Story is the Hemingway line’s “don’t underestimate me” cigar. Sure, it’s only 4 inches long, but it packs a flavor punch that can stand up to its bigger brothers. It’s perfect for those moments when you want a quality smoke but don’t have an hour to spare.
From the first puff, I always get a warm burst of cedar and a sweetness that’s reminiscent of maple syrup—if maple syrup came with a hint of black pepper to keep things interesting. By the halfway point, I start to notice a nuttiness that balances out the spice, making it a well-rounded experience from start to finish.
Who’s it for?
The guy (or gal) on the go. Or someone who wants to dip their toes into the Hemingway line without committing to a longer smoke.
Best Seller: The Goldilocks of the Hemingway Line
Specs:
- Size: 4.5 x 55
- Smoke Time: ~50-60 minutes
- Flavor Notes: Maple, cedar, nutmeg, and a touch of espresso
The Best Seller is like the middle child of the Hemingway family: slightly bigger than the Short Story but not as intimidating as the Signature or Work of Art. At 4.5 inches, it gives you just enough smoking time to feel indulgent without overcommitting.
What sets the Best Seller apart is its balance. The wider ring gauge cools the smoke, allowing the flavors to really shine. It starts with the same sweet cedar and maple combo as the Short Story but adds a deeper complexity as you go. By the final third, I always catch some hints of espresso and nutmeg, making it a little richer and more nuanced than its smaller sibling.
Who’s it for?
The seasoned smoker who wants something substantial but manageable—or the newbie looking for a “step up” cigar.
Short Story vs. Best Seller: The Verdict
So, which one takes the crown? For me, it’s the Best Seller.
Don’t get me wrong, the Short Story is a fantastic little cigar. It’s reliable, flavorful, and perfect for those quick smoke breaks. But the Best Seller wins me over with its slightly longer smoke time and fuller flavor profile. It feels like you’re getting more of the Hemingway experience without stretching it out too much.
That said, the choice really comes down to what you’re looking for. If you’re pressed for time, go Short Story. If you’ve got an hour and want to savor every second, the Best Seller has your back (and some more complexity too).
Final Thoughts: Why You Should Try the Hemingway Line
The Arturo Fuente Hemingway line is a must-try for anyone who appreciates quality cigars. Whether you’re a seasoned aficionado or just getting started, these Perfectos offer a smoking experience that’s both accessible and exceptional.
And hey, even if you don’t fall in love with the Short Story or Best Seller, the Hemingway lineup has plenty of other sizes to explore. It’s like a buffet of handcrafted goodness—only instead of mashed potatoes and gravy, you get cedar, spice, and a touch of nostalgia.
So, grab one (or both), pour yourself something nice, and enjoy a little piece of cigar history. Trust me, Hemingway himself would approve.
